Home » Issues » Articles » Torah Thoughts » The Promise of the Land: By Rabbi Mordechai Rabinovitz

The Promise of the Land: By Rabbi Mordechai Rabinovitz

It is generally assumed that the inalienable right of the Jewish people to the Land of Israel

is based on the promise by Hashem to our forefathers Abraham, Isaac, and Jacob. Since

the Talmud (Berachos 7a) states that divine promises for good things are not rescinded by

Hashem even if the recipient is no longer deserving, this promise would seem irrevocable.

However, Rambam (Introduction to Mishnah Commentary) qualifies that rule and asserts

that a divine promise for the good is not irreversible if it was communicated to a prophet for

the prophecy as a personal message from G-d, without a command to convey it to others.

When a promise is communicated to a prophet for his ears alone, then even a good promise

can be rescinded.

But in that case, a serious problem arises. Because elsewhere, Rambam (Guide 2:39) states

that the very first prophet in history to receive a command to communicate his prophecy

to others was Moses. Now, if the promise to the forefathers is what gives us a right to the

Holy Land, and if the forefathers received that promise in a personal prophecy, not for

communication to others, how can we (according to Rambam) be certain that the promise

will be fulfilled?

The answer would seem to be given in this week’s reading (Shemos 6:6-9): Hashem spoke to

Moshe and said to him: “Say to the people of Israel, I will take you out… and I will bring you

to the land that I promised to give to Abraham, Isaac and Jacob, and I will give it to you as a

heritage, I am Hashem”.

As can clearly be seen, Hashem here commands Moshe to communicate the promise to the

people of Israel. Accordingly, this promise cannot be rescinded even if we are not always so


Today, we are witnessing the fulfillment of that promise by Hashem, and are certain that

likewise all other promises of good to our people will be fulfilled, speedily in our days!


You must be logged in to post a comment.