Torah Portions

The Weekly Torah Portion of Shmot
The Leadership of Moses -- Two Types of Leaders

 Adapted from Midbar Shur by Rabbi Avraham Yitzchak Hakohen Kook
By Rabbi Chanan Morrison

When God informed Moses that he was to bring the Jewish people out of Egypt, Moses did not accept the assignment happily. "Who am I that I should go to Pharaoh?" [Ex. 3:11] The Midrash explained Moses' objection with the following parable:

 "A king once married off his daughter. He promised to give her a lady to wait upon her. However, the king only provided the daughter with a lowly maidservant. His son-in-law complained, 'Did you not promise to give her a lady to serve her?"

So said Moses before God: 'Master of the universe! When Jacob went down to Egypt, did You not say to him, 'I will go down with you to Egypt and I will surely take you out'? And now You say, 'I am sending you to Pharaoh'!" [Shemot Rabbah 3:4]

According to the Midrash, Moses objected to leading the Israelites because he felt that God had promised to do the job Himself. Did Moses really think that God would lead them out of Egypt without a human emissary?

 Also, we need to examine God's response to Moses:

 "Indeed, I will be with you. Proof that I have sent you will come when you bring the people out of Egypt -- then you will serve God on this mountain" [Ex. 3:12].

How does serving God on Mount Sinai prove that God Himself will lead the people? How did it allay Moses' fears about his mission?

Two Types of Leaders

Generally speaking, we may distinguish between two types of successful leaders. The first category is leaders who excel in organizational skills. The leader himself does not contribute or add to the nation's accomplishments, but he knows how to bring together the various abilities and talents dispersed amongst the people. By marshalling together their scattered strengths, such a leader gently steers the people to their destiny.

The second type of leader is more than just an efficient organizer. He uses his own special qualities and gifts to inspire the people to greater aspirations. Such a leader is not merely an instrument of heaven to rule the people; he is a dynamic individual, blessed with extraordinary wisdom and holiness, capable of uplifting the people to a level that they could not reach on the basis of their own merits.

These two types of leaders induce change in different ways. The competent leader gradually leads his people to their national goals, step-by-step. The charismatic leader, on the other hand, inspires the people to attain new heights in a sudden and dramatic fashion.

 Moses' Complaint  

This distinction allows us to understand Moses' objection. In all likelihood, Moses recognized that he was destined to lead the Jewish people. His miraculous rescue as a baby and his extraordinary childhood growing up in Pharaoh's palace, clearly indicated that Moses was meant to lead his people.

In his humility, however, Moses placed himself in the first category of leaders -- those without any special qualities of their own, just the willingness to organize and govern the people. God, however, had promised a dramatic redemption, a quantum leap in the people's spiritual elevation, when He said "I will surely raise up"  [Gen. 46:4] Clearly, God had intended that a charismatic leader would inspire and ennoble the people.

Like the son-in-law in the parable, Moses objected to God's choice of leader. The King had promised a lady of high caliber -- a great and inspiring leader. But He had only provided a lowly maid-servant -- Moses, a competent but unremarkable public servant.

Therefore, God explained to Moses, "I will be with you." With the sublime powers that I bestow upon you, you will be able to uplift the people to a level beyond their current reach. In this way, I will fulfill My promise.

And God continued: the proof that you will be the catalyst for a profound national change is that the people will stand on Mount Sinai. In order to merit receiving the Torah, the Jewish People will need to be on the highest spiritual level. Were that not the case, the Torah could have been revealed to an earlier generation. The arrival of the Jewish People at Mount Sinai was proof that Moses would in fact be the second type of leader, dramatically readying them for this historic moment.